What I hear Kress saying here, is that, in alphabetic text, genre-mixing was once an embarrassment, ('dis is bad), but in multimodal texts, genres must, by the text's very mixed nature, be mixed and so, multimodal mixed genre writing is good (52). I guess, first off, that makes me wonder how true/widespread it is (was?) that mixed-genre writing is a negative thing--is it individual perspective, or all the turkeys in a field?
I love what Kress gets to in the end of his chapter, because based on the way he was defining genre in the beginning, I felt the same familiar frustration I get when people talk about genre's as fixed entities. My limited experience shows that, if genres are as rigid as Kress starts out intimating, writers drift in and out of genre's all the time, based upon the social interaction invited by the perspective. And that seems like too tight of a way to define genre.
Shouldn't we be able to write and represent many different social perspectives and interactions, while still remaining within a genre? Take academic writing, for example: most students describe it as being exceedingly dry and boring, but within the range of academic writers, some write in first person and include narratives that are inviting and friendly, no matter how dense the rest of the writing (the density makes it difficult reading for an outsider, even if it is not boring or dry).
Still other academic writers write in a disconnected way that just sounds so official that I feel like I shouldn't connect their writing to anything in the real world--because they are "above reality". But isn't this all considered academic writing? Alright, enough of an aside, I just haven't been stoked on rigid ideas of genre, because at this point in my education, I feel like they are unrealistic. I'm happy that multimodal writing forces open the door on mixed-genre writing. Maybe we've seen the light.
What I thought was really neat about Kress's analysis was how it opened my eyes to just how much you can see in a writer's perspective by how they write. My own initial reaction to the two writing samples (somewhat telling) was very simple: The first was personal, the second professional. The first is how I'd write the assignment if I was at home, having fun with science; the second one is how I would've written in response to a school assignment--both as a kid and maybe now (if I had to choose between the two writing samples), because I default to thinking of science as not being a friendly walk through what someone experienced, but as factual, "do X, Y, Z and you'll get the same results". I think of science, although performed by a person, like it's supposed to be impersonal-sounding and disconnected. Yeah, I'm working on that....
But I had to laugh at Kress's analysis, because I never thought of the second writing sample as representing an interaction written from the perspective of one whose world is commanded. I just thought, "this sounds more professional, more scientific". (If the shoe fits? Yikes! 'Course, this is coming from a girl who, when asked to write "professional" school papers in junior high school, adopted some mixture of old English and lawyer-speak, and thought it was how college writing would be....)
The side-effect of my reading of Kress is that I'm so intrigued by the window into personal/social interactional ideas that he draws from people's writing, that I'm going to be going around reading to find these things he draws out. It's very cool.
Last, but certainly not least, let me recount these words that were like music to my writerly ears,
"A newer way of thinking may be that within a general awareness or the range of genres, of their shapes and their contexts, speakers and writers newly make the generic forms out of available resources. This is much more "generative" notion of genre: not one where you learn the shapes of existing kinds of text along, in order to replicate them, but where you learn the generative rules of constitution of generic form within the power structures of society. And you learn what the shapes of these texts are, coming out of those social conditions. That will permit (and account for) constant change, and makes the actions of the producer of the genre innovative and transformative. It encourages and normalizes "design" of text in response to the perceived needs of the make of the text in a given environment. In such theory all acts of representation are innovative, and creativity is the normal process of representation for all" (53-54).
<Deep breath> Wait, did I just hear the chink of a writer's prison door opening? Of fetters falling to the cold, stone floor? Did I just hear that I, as a writer, am actually in charge of my writing? That creativity belongs in every genre? That I'm allowed movement, even within genre, based on context, social structure and personal exigence? (I feel that so often, we claim to be in charge of our writing--that we can write what we will--but we are not: we are tied and fettered to our ideas of "right writing"--that just maybe need some C4 applied to them...)
Whenever I see movement, I get excited, because life moves, and in the same way, I believe writing should be allowed to move--genres included. Past generations are now applauded for changes the world resisted during their time. Why are we any different? If we will remain relevant to a shifting world, I agree with Kress: we need rhetorical eyes that see why genres are structured as they are (societal why's), so that we can shift our writing powerfully to meet new social needs as they present themselves around us.
Of Mountains and Water
Who we are is more persuasive than our words will ever be.
Monday, November 28, 2011
Sunday, November 13, 2011
Can You Out-Write a Computer?
In Eli Pariser's presentation, I was struck by the thought of the very internet we want to connect us being a force that isolates us fro new ideas--and that without our knowledge and consent. The idea reminded me of stories I used to read when I was a teenager, about the Iron Curtain and the Censors that took out whatever information the government didn't want the people to know.
Wile I don't think that this is a similar situation as far as intent is concerned, it very much bothers me that, while I think I am fulfilling my moral and ethical (and personal curiosity desire) to gain knowledge, I can actually be only finding as much information as someone, somewhere (and an algorithm writer, at that!) has deemed that I should. It is very much my own personal responsibility to educate myself, but again, I am quite flabbergasted that there is a program that has already decided what it is I might want to see.
Part of the reason this is so outrageous to me is that I don't even know what I want to know. I can only decided this once I have the information at my fingertips. Our worlds are closed enough due to our human desire to be right, and to argue our point at the cost of interaction with others of varying perspectives; why close our worlds further by taking away the very conflicting and oft-unwelcome information we may be hoping not to find?
This algorithmic situation Pariser speaks of is not like machines have taken over our minds all sci-fi style, this seems to me to be people who programs these filters. And I'm guessing they are not Big Brother, or our enemies, so at some point, they thought (or some company thought), that this filtering would be a benefitial idea. None of us are expempt from buying into ideas that put our ability to learn with open minds at risk. I think the lesson I take away from this are two:
1) Even if I have 795,428 results in .08seconds, I still don't necessarily have information for a balanced perspective, and
2) Where are the places in my own life where I might make a decision to keep some metaphorical filter that blocks things I need to know--that I don't even know that I need to know and wont recognize that I'm missing?
Pariser and Begos both mention a need for transparency: I don't hear a "don't filter", but more a "tell us what you're basing those filters on", which I think are very reasonable points.
Wait, so is the Panda program described by Heffernan--is this very thing that Pariser is begging Google to make transparent?
And then there's Bunz. Boy am I glad that is not my last name! On a more serious note, I'm sorry, if writing that can almost pass as human can be accomplished by a computer, with the simple push of a button, then that calls us to examine exactly what we are in this class: what is writing? If a computer can take stats and make them a newspaper article in just a few seconds, then what need is there for human writers? (Or what part of this "writing" is accomplished by humans?) I don't like that. To me it underlines how damaging it is to our field when peopel reduce writing to mere rules. A computer can write using rules, sure. What can we human writers do? Everything that rules can't dictate or decide--all the good stuff! That's a right I think we should cherish, share and protect. One way I thing we can do that is to not look so closely at what rules we think might make good writers of us, and be willing to put in the time to find our own voice, our own message (exigence), and learn how best we can get that meaning across. There is something a computer can't do (yet?).
My new motto: write like a human! (But what does a human write like? That depends upon the human, doesn't it? In my thinking, it sure should.
Wile I don't think that this is a similar situation as far as intent is concerned, it very much bothers me that, while I think I am fulfilling my moral and ethical (and personal curiosity desire) to gain knowledge, I can actually be only finding as much information as someone, somewhere (and an algorithm writer, at that!) has deemed that I should. It is very much my own personal responsibility to educate myself, but again, I am quite flabbergasted that there is a program that has already decided what it is I might want to see.
Part of the reason this is so outrageous to me is that I don't even know what I want to know. I can only decided this once I have the information at my fingertips. Our worlds are closed enough due to our human desire to be right, and to argue our point at the cost of interaction with others of varying perspectives; why close our worlds further by taking away the very conflicting and oft-unwelcome information we may be hoping not to find?
This algorithmic situation Pariser speaks of is not like machines have taken over our minds all sci-fi style, this seems to me to be people who programs these filters. And I'm guessing they are not Big Brother, or our enemies, so at some point, they thought (or some company thought), that this filtering would be a benefitial idea. None of us are expempt from buying into ideas that put our ability to learn with open minds at risk. I think the lesson I take away from this are two:
1) Even if I have 795,428 results in .08seconds, I still don't necessarily have information for a balanced perspective, and
2) Where are the places in my own life where I might make a decision to keep some metaphorical filter that blocks things I need to know--that I don't even know that I need to know and wont recognize that I'm missing?
Pariser and Begos both mention a need for transparency: I don't hear a "don't filter", but more a "tell us what you're basing those filters on", which I think are very reasonable points.
Wait, so is the Panda program described by Heffernan--is this very thing that Pariser is begging Google to make transparent?
And then there's Bunz. Boy am I glad that is not my last name! On a more serious note, I'm sorry, if writing that can almost pass as human can be accomplished by a computer, with the simple push of a button, then that calls us to examine exactly what we are in this class: what is writing? If a computer can take stats and make them a newspaper article in just a few seconds, then what need is there for human writers? (Or what part of this "writing" is accomplished by humans?) I don't like that. To me it underlines how damaging it is to our field when peopel reduce writing to mere rules. A computer can write using rules, sure. What can we human writers do? Everything that rules can't dictate or decide--all the good stuff! That's a right I think we should cherish, share and protect. One way I thing we can do that is to not look so closely at what rules we think might make good writers of us, and be willing to put in the time to find our own voice, our own message (exigence), and learn how best we can get that meaning across. There is something a computer can't do (yet?).
My new motto: write like a human! (But what does a human write like? That depends upon the human, doesn't it? In my thinking, it sure should.
Friday, November 4, 2011
Chris Anderson's TED Talk
I wanted to blog about both videos, but the Anderson one was so interesting it'd be too long to write about both.
First, I was super intrigued by my own response to watching a video text rather than reading a paper, alphabetic text. Normally I watch these close enough to class time that I don't need notes. This time I knew I'd need notes. I noted (sorry :-) that my entire "reading" process is different when I try to take notes from a video.
For one thing, taking notes off of a video led to less quoting and more paraphrasing for me: I was going to quote that text at 1:58 that starts, "Dancers have created a whole global laboratory online..." and goes on about kids in Japan watching a dance movie made in Detroit, then adding to it and republishing it to YouTube within a week, while dancers in CA are remixing the Japanese one and making a whole new dance style. I was going to quote it. (interesting I was going to quote the only chunk of alphabetic text visible in the whole video. Why that?) But I couldn't copy and paste. And I didn't want to retype all that. And then I wasn't sure who said it because that was not written in the quote, and to spell it right I'd have to not only hear it on the video again, but try and Google it for the right spelling too. So I paraphrased. A lot.
I found the following reaction even more odd: the writing in that quote seems to have links in it, for some of those terms are a different color, in places it would make sense to link to sites that describe them. Even though I normally complain about being distracted by too many links in a post, I felt I was missing out because I could see there was information there, but I had no way of knowing where it went to. Odd. I had no idea I was so trained to use these tech features that I'd miss them if they were indicated by a cue on the screen but not available.
By the way, it's not fair that we in class are having to take sides and argue something that we would argue totally different had we read the reading (or video) for the next week! =) If I can hack it, I'm reading ahead! (Cheating!!!) No, truly, I keep being struck by how we argue something so strongly--collectively unsure, but sounding personally convinced--yet the next reading speaks exactly to the issues we were debating. Very nice set up. I'm so still reading ahead! :-)
The Chris guy from Kenya was deeply inspiring to me. I loved how he showed this, in a powerful way through their story, then said it in so few words:
"Changes happens when we see things in a different way."
That reminded me of why a big part of my heart believes in originality: people have told me stuff I needed to know till they were tired of saying it, and I didn't get it. But then something happened--usually an experience--that caused me to be able to see in a very different way--the way they had tried to convince me of. I've come to think that, It is not knowledge as fact that changes perspective, but knowledge as experience that changes it. Hence how I could "know" things new to me without every being able to see differently, but when the knowledge became personal experience that wrapped me up in itself, I couldn't help but see differently. I think many actions, hopes, beliefs, and dreams stem from what we see (here meaning, what we experience--truly see) and then also what we choose to focus on. Moments of personal originality, I would say, have little to do with factual knowledge, or even expounded factual knowledge. An original idea is born when a person who was blind to something suddenly sees differently. Like Chris said, "Changes happens when we see things in a different way."
Sunday, October 30, 2011
What DOESN'T Count As Writing?
It's more than halfway through the semester and I finally think something is getting through my thick skull: the question is not What counts as writing? but What doesn't count as writing? Johnson-Eilola talks at length about Web Logs (blogs), and particularly on pages 216 and 217 about one called "Plastic", and as I was reading that section, I just got overwhelmed with the enormity of the different kinds of writing all going on all over this website, and how--as he says--none of it fits within the traditional rules of citation and authorship.
It seems like, when talking about writing or teaching writing, so many people focus most on issues of plagiarism, proper citation, and all that jazz. (Like the most important thing about writing is scaring people into being afraid to have any ideas based on other writers' ideas because that might be plagiarism...grrrrr--but I digress.) So, I'm wondering, if much of the writing going on in our world today doesn't even have the ability to fit into the very broad category of author and citation--if there are not even clear traditional roles in the field of writing (like editors and publishers), as we experience it today, how important are the ideas that are being harped upon that all have to do with those roles?
And yet I have to go back to what Johnson-Eilola says in the beginning, "exploring contradictions as necessary conditions of existence" (200). I can't say I grasp all of what he says throughout his article, so maybe he says this and I just can't grasp it yet, but I'm stuck on the question of how to make money as an author in a world where one doesn't just write old-fashioned, paper-and-bound books? I know he's talking about people being charged a lot of money to use tiny parts of texts, but we're talking about websites here--and I don't mean like Google. To bring it closer to home, I'm a blogger. I've written at least as much as a good-sized book in my posts. Do I make money off it? No. But without being a shameless advertisement whore, I don't know how (I can't bear the idea of whatever the Adsense Google app is that is supposed to earn me income off my blog--it just seems like so much salesmanship on writing that wasn't meant to be that; like putting coupons in a research book...). But Web Logs are such a media of the now--what I write wouldn't even go in a book--how do I further my writing career, not just my writing hobby? Looking forward to this conversation in class so I can understand more what J-E was talking about in terms of the money aspect of this.
Returning to my original question, What doesn't count as writing? I am toying with a kinda radical thought (to me): writing is every kind of human interaction we use, aside from face-to-face interaction. Ya think? And if that is true (I'm not sure that it is, but it's seeming plausible), then we don't use rhetoric in our writing at all: writing is rhetoric. If rhetoric is basic human interaction at its core (that is, we can't interact without using it), and writing is every kind of interaction we do other than in person, writing has to be rhetoric.
My head is spinning a little at those thoughts. I'd love to hear your thoughts for or against this craziness.
It seems like, when talking about writing or teaching writing, so many people focus most on issues of plagiarism, proper citation, and all that jazz. (Like the most important thing about writing is scaring people into being afraid to have any ideas based on other writers' ideas because that might be plagiarism...grrrrr--but I digress.) So, I'm wondering, if much of the writing going on in our world today doesn't even have the ability to fit into the very broad category of author and citation--if there are not even clear traditional roles in the field of writing (like editors and publishers), as we experience it today, how important are the ideas that are being harped upon that all have to do with those roles?
And yet I have to go back to what Johnson-Eilola says in the beginning, "exploring contradictions as necessary conditions of existence" (200). I can't say I grasp all of what he says throughout his article, so maybe he says this and I just can't grasp it yet, but I'm stuck on the question of how to make money as an author in a world where one doesn't just write old-fashioned, paper-and-bound books? I know he's talking about people being charged a lot of money to use tiny parts of texts, but we're talking about websites here--and I don't mean like Google. To bring it closer to home, I'm a blogger. I've written at least as much as a good-sized book in my posts. Do I make money off it? No. But without being a shameless advertisement whore, I don't know how (I can't bear the idea of whatever the Adsense Google app is that is supposed to earn me income off my blog--it just seems like so much salesmanship on writing that wasn't meant to be that; like putting coupons in a research book...). But Web Logs are such a media of the now--what I write wouldn't even go in a book--how do I further my writing career, not just my writing hobby? Looking forward to this conversation in class so I can understand more what J-E was talking about in terms of the money aspect of this.
Returning to my original question, What doesn't count as writing? I am toying with a kinda radical thought (to me): writing is every kind of human interaction we use, aside from face-to-face interaction. Ya think? And if that is true (I'm not sure that it is, but it's seeming plausible), then we don't use rhetoric in our writing at all: writing is rhetoric. If rhetoric is basic human interaction at its core (that is, we can't interact without using it), and writing is every kind of interaction we do other than in person, writing has to be rhetoric.
My head is spinning a little at those thoughts. I'd love to hear your thoughts for or against this craziness.
Wednesday, October 26, 2011
PS--Thanks!
I meant to say this at the beginning of my last post but totally spaced it out. I just wanted to thank those of you who spoke to my question about students not (very often) talking to their professors outside of class. I truly appreciate the thoughts.
And I have another question (you had to know this was coming...):
If you don't talk to your professors outside of class, how will you make connections that you might not yet even know are possible? Like... your research ideas being affirmed as applying to an actual field of study, not just class. And being told that there is a conference that might really find your research interesting. And hey, why don't you develop that a little more and submit it for publishing in this journal or that website?
It makes me sad that there is an entire world of possibilities like this open to students, and yet so many don't even know they exist. How different could 4 years of college be if we came out of it with writing published, and conferences attended--so, connections made that can't usually be made just by doing really good schoolwork in class? I think the saddest look I've seen on a student's face since I got here was a very invested, talented senior who, mid-senior year discovered all the opportunities like these that she had, but didn't know she had, until it was too late (as an undergrad, anyway).
Apologies if I'm being all big sisterly on ya--I can't help it, I'm the oldest of 6 kids and I'm the loudest cheerleader for their dreams--but I can't help but be awed that the opportunities of the past two years have very literally changed my life. It started by being afraid I was a freakin' pain in the ass, but daring to try and strike up a conversation with professors about their work anyway. Not everyone you try is a good fit, but you'll find one or two that your ideas mesh with, and who gives a crap about your dreams--and sees what you could do with them maybe even more than you. I gotta tell ya, that makes school a whole different experience--not just about grades and getting a mythical "degree", but about being equipped for life; about having actual, measurable steps to get to your dreams.
The point of talking to professors isn't brown-nosing or ass-kissing like it's accused by so many students of being--it's about opportunities, and dreams, and education being worth all the hard work we put into it because it makes a place for us now--not just years and years from now.
Okay, sorry, I'll quit now--I just wanted to thank you for your answers to my last question, felt I owed some explanation for my curiosity, and my educational experience has been so very life-altering that I get all caught up hoping everyone else's can be too. :-)
And I have another question (you had to know this was coming...):
If you don't talk to your professors outside of class, how will you make connections that you might not yet even know are possible? Like... your research ideas being affirmed as applying to an actual field of study, not just class. And being told that there is a conference that might really find your research interesting. And hey, why don't you develop that a little more and submit it for publishing in this journal or that website?
It makes me sad that there is an entire world of possibilities like this open to students, and yet so many don't even know they exist. How different could 4 years of college be if we came out of it with writing published, and conferences attended--so, connections made that can't usually be made just by doing really good schoolwork in class? I think the saddest look I've seen on a student's face since I got here was a very invested, talented senior who, mid-senior year discovered all the opportunities like these that she had, but didn't know she had, until it was too late (as an undergrad, anyway).
Apologies if I'm being all big sisterly on ya--I can't help it, I'm the oldest of 6 kids and I'm the loudest cheerleader for their dreams--but I can't help but be awed that the opportunities of the past two years have very literally changed my life. It started by being afraid I was a freakin' pain in the ass, but daring to try and strike up a conversation with professors about their work anyway. Not everyone you try is a good fit, but you'll find one or two that your ideas mesh with, and who gives a crap about your dreams--and sees what you could do with them maybe even more than you. I gotta tell ya, that makes school a whole different experience--not just about grades and getting a mythical "degree", but about being equipped for life; about having actual, measurable steps to get to your dreams.
The point of talking to professors isn't brown-nosing or ass-kissing like it's accused by so many students of being--it's about opportunities, and dreams, and education being worth all the hard work we put into it because it makes a place for us now--not just years and years from now.
Okay, sorry, I'll quit now--I just wanted to thank you for your answers to my last question, felt I owed some explanation for my curiosity, and my educational experience has been so very life-altering that I get all caught up hoping everyone else's can be too. :-)
Monday, October 24, 2011
Prisoners of the Window We Look Through
I am rather overwhelmed at the amount of interesting ideas that Landham talks about. None are new to the class--I feel they are very much what we have been discussing, but expressed in deeper fashion.
I'm not sure I know enough about this to write smartly about it, but I'm going to attempt it--it's what I see in Landham more than anything.
He addresses the issue that multimodal writing is demanding that we redefine literacy. "Electronic technology has prompted so hostile a response from the humanities establishment because it creates a different literacy from our customary print-based one" (160). I think this is cool, because I was already wondering about that here. I feel that the present move to focus on multimodal writing, reading, and literacy creates a perfect challenge for rhetoric to gain some credibility (other than the current "All that political BS" that the world seems to view it as now).
I think Landham refers to it as chaos theory, but I think he means (or should mean!) rhetorical theory. "Whatever else it may be, the new mixture of word, image, and sound that digital communication brings with it will be radically non-linear, associative, discontinuous, interactive" (160). That sounds a lot like rhetoric to me. Rhetoric seems based in two very important concepts: 1) looking with open eyes at the way things are right now, with an eye toward their context in past and present, and 2) human interaction. To embrace either of these dynamics of rhetoric, we have to let loose the idea that things should be a certain way--enough to be able to see and work from the way they are presently. Landham's words to this are strong, "Because we have thought photographs, like 'black-and-white' words, to be unalterable talismans of truth, like long-time prisoners we shudder when our chains are removed. But all these fixities are technological conventions, not eternal truths" (157).
What I sense that Landham is getting at here is that this digital era, this multimodal writing, is challenging the very core principles that humanities education has been based in. I might be wrong, because this is fuzzy for me, but I hear Landham saying that humanities community has been built upon the assumption that form is separate from content, that "the printed page was a transparent window onto the world of thought" (157). The very invent of writing on screen challenges that concept (without a word from those who already argued its validity--it is self evident--or seems so to me), "So. We have an expressive surface which can now mix word, written and spoken, with image and music" (157). And suddenly the very literal "window" of a computer screen has shown the metaphoric "window" that is alphabetic text for what it is: a farce. How is it even logical to imagine that letters and words--both actually symbolic and themselves pictures and icons in some sense--are but a window to see thought through with no tint of their own to color the thoughts? No, The very text itself contributes to the thought it conveys, as I will show.
Since when did human beings ever have the capability to separate themselves totally from their experience and view the world in a vacuum? We are complex beings, are we not? Furthermore, our knowledge is created through experience--even if it is merely the experience of words on a page (it is not merely this, but for this argument, we won't go there), so to truly be able to see through words to the thoughts behind them, we would have to somehow forget all the knowledge we have amassed, right? That's incredulous.
Just how incredulous? Pretend that before you are two paper documents. One is preschool triple-lined paper with crayon writing--the letters are not uniform and they look very much like a kindergartner's work. It's an important thought though--it delineates the details of a home mortgage you just found out you qualify for. The other is letterhead from an important bank, and it details the same particulars of the home mortgage you just found out you qualify for. Which one do you take seriously? If you received only the one written in crayon in an envelope from said mortgage company, would you conclude it was bad joke? Oh, so you mean you can't just ignore the text on paper? Huh. interesting.
I find it almost impossible to believe that professionals whose job is to analyze text have held the "clear container" belief to be true, but Landham says multimodality is challenging the entire paradigm: "This transparent medium was for humanism what Newtonian physics was for science--a fundamental paradigm. Pure conceptual thought, unintermediated by expression, was possible and indeed ideal. The printed page was a transparent window onto the world of thought" (157).
It seems to me that the upsurge of multimodality is asking those who see themselves as "guardians of a way of literacy or life" to wake up and see that culture has moved on. Landham notes, "...books create a natural authority: you can quarrel with them but only marginally or by writing another book" (155). With the invent of text on screen where it can be cut and pasted at will, society has fucked with what has stood as social authority for decades and, "The whole system of cultural authority we inherited from Renaissance Humanism thus evaporates, literally, at a stroke" (155). This must be a scary concept for they who thought themselves to be the authority on what is legitimate text, writing, and literacy.
I wonder how much of this attitude I'm talking about pervades how much we as students participate or not--depending upon what paradigm we were raised in. I was raised revering printed text--books. Anything else was lesser somehow. It still strikes me as strange that I can go onto a blog written by professors for professors and comment on it. Who am I to make my voice heard in that forum? And yet, multimodality gives me a voice, and direct access to an author's ear, where before, I might merely have read their book and talked about it with my friends--there never would have been the equal interaction the multimodlity affords me.
That leads me back to my original point, but from a little different angle: call it chaos theory or rhetorical theory, people are interacting more around texts. Students can interact and even "argue" with their faculty (and authors of their textbooks), sometimes even via Facebook. That changes so many things. The paradigm seems to be shifting away from what things should be, to what they are; from authority to interaction. I see multimodal texts forcing those of the old paradigm of "words are a clear window we see thought through" to either close their eyes and become more irrelevant, or realize that rhetoric defines literacy too.
Literacy isn't above rhetorical theory, but subservient to it. Literacy is situated. It happens to be situated in the here and now, where nobody knows exactly what is going on. That chaos is cool. It gives "nobodies" a chance to talk to "somebodies", it makes "dead" texts that were stuck to one page now "alive" and interact-able-with. You know what I think? Is literacy at risk? Hell no! Literacy is more real and more accessible than ever before--but to see through that window, you have to be willing to shift your paradigm--perhaps into overdrive.
I'm not sure I know enough about this to write smartly about it, but I'm going to attempt it--it's what I see in Landham more than anything.
He addresses the issue that multimodal writing is demanding that we redefine literacy. "Electronic technology has prompted so hostile a response from the humanities establishment because it creates a different literacy from our customary print-based one" (160). I think this is cool, because I was already wondering about that here. I feel that the present move to focus on multimodal writing, reading, and literacy creates a perfect challenge for rhetoric to gain some credibility (other than the current "All that political BS" that the world seems to view it as now).
I think Landham refers to it as chaos theory, but I think he means (or should mean!) rhetorical theory. "Whatever else it may be, the new mixture of word, image, and sound that digital communication brings with it will be radically non-linear, associative, discontinuous, interactive" (160). That sounds a lot like rhetoric to me. Rhetoric seems based in two very important concepts: 1) looking with open eyes at the way things are right now, with an eye toward their context in past and present, and 2) human interaction. To embrace either of these dynamics of rhetoric, we have to let loose the idea that things should be a certain way--enough to be able to see and work from the way they are presently. Landham's words to this are strong, "Because we have thought photographs, like 'black-and-white' words, to be unalterable talismans of truth, like long-time prisoners we shudder when our chains are removed. But all these fixities are technological conventions, not eternal truths" (157).
What I sense that Landham is getting at here is that this digital era, this multimodal writing, is challenging the very core principles that humanities education has been based in. I might be wrong, because this is fuzzy for me, but I hear Landham saying that humanities community has been built upon the assumption that form is separate from content, that "the printed page was a transparent window onto the world of thought" (157). The very invent of writing on screen challenges that concept (without a word from those who already argued its validity--it is self evident--or seems so to me), "So. We have an expressive surface which can now mix word, written and spoken, with image and music" (157). And suddenly the very literal "window" of a computer screen has shown the metaphoric "window" that is alphabetic text for what it is: a farce. How is it even logical to imagine that letters and words--both actually symbolic and themselves pictures and icons in some sense--are but a window to see thought through with no tint of their own to color the thoughts? No, The very text itself contributes to the thought it conveys, as I will show.
Since when did human beings ever have the capability to separate themselves totally from their experience and view the world in a vacuum? We are complex beings, are we not? Furthermore, our knowledge is created through experience--even if it is merely the experience of words on a page (it is not merely this, but for this argument, we won't go there), so to truly be able to see through words to the thoughts behind them, we would have to somehow forget all the knowledge we have amassed, right? That's incredulous.
Just how incredulous? Pretend that before you are two paper documents. One is preschool triple-lined paper with crayon writing--the letters are not uniform and they look very much like a kindergartner's work. It's an important thought though--it delineates the details of a home mortgage you just found out you qualify for. The other is letterhead from an important bank, and it details the same particulars of the home mortgage you just found out you qualify for. Which one do you take seriously? If you received only the one written in crayon in an envelope from said mortgage company, would you conclude it was bad joke? Oh, so you mean you can't just ignore the text on paper? Huh. interesting.
I find it almost impossible to believe that professionals whose job is to analyze text have held the "clear container" belief to be true, but Landham says multimodality is challenging the entire paradigm: "This transparent medium was for humanism what Newtonian physics was for science--a fundamental paradigm. Pure conceptual thought, unintermediated by expression, was possible and indeed ideal. The printed page was a transparent window onto the world of thought" (157).
It seems to me that the upsurge of multimodality is asking those who see themselves as "guardians of a way of literacy or life" to wake up and see that culture has moved on. Landham notes, "...books create a natural authority: you can quarrel with them but only marginally or by writing another book" (155). With the invent of text on screen where it can be cut and pasted at will, society has fucked with what has stood as social authority for decades and, "The whole system of cultural authority we inherited from Renaissance Humanism thus evaporates, literally, at a stroke" (155). This must be a scary concept for they who thought themselves to be the authority on what is legitimate text, writing, and literacy.
I wonder how much of this attitude I'm talking about pervades how much we as students participate or not--depending upon what paradigm we were raised in. I was raised revering printed text--books. Anything else was lesser somehow. It still strikes me as strange that I can go onto a blog written by professors for professors and comment on it. Who am I to make my voice heard in that forum? And yet, multimodality gives me a voice, and direct access to an author's ear, where before, I might merely have read their book and talked about it with my friends--there never would have been the equal interaction the multimodlity affords me.
That leads me back to my original point, but from a little different angle: call it chaos theory or rhetorical theory, people are interacting more around texts. Students can interact and even "argue" with their faculty (and authors of their textbooks), sometimes even via Facebook. That changes so many things. The paradigm seems to be shifting away from what things should be, to what they are; from authority to interaction. I see multimodal texts forcing those of the old paradigm of "words are a clear window we see thought through" to either close their eyes and become more irrelevant, or realize that rhetoric defines literacy too.
Literacy isn't above rhetorical theory, but subservient to it. Literacy is situated. It happens to be situated in the here and now, where nobody knows exactly what is going on. That chaos is cool. It gives "nobodies" a chance to talk to "somebodies", it makes "dead" texts that were stuck to one page now "alive" and interact-able-with. You know what I think? Is literacy at risk? Hell no! Literacy is more real and more accessible than ever before--but to see through that window, you have to be willing to shift your paradigm--perhaps into overdrive.
Friday, October 21, 2011
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
