Saturday, September 3, 2011

Grant-Davie; Covino and Jolliffe

It's interesting looking at rhetoric and how it applies to the digital world. Although I've been studying rhetoric for a bit now, I have looked mostly at how it applies to texts and live, human interaction--not anything multimodal or digital.

As I was reading Covino and Jolliffe, I came across a passage that prompted me to do a little reflecting on how I view and use websites. The authors were quoting Roland Barthes as saying, "In this ideal text, the networks are many and interact, without any one of them being able to surpass the rest; this text is a galaxy of signifiers, not structure of signifieds..." And then a bit farther down they quote Kenneth Burke as saying, "A way of seeing is also a way of not seeing" (5).

Those quotes stimulated a few points of thought on this subject of the rhetorical situation and how it applies to multimodal writing:

1) "...a galaxy of signifiers, not structure of signifieds..." Now what the heck does that mean? It haunted me for a bit until I connected it with the second passage and started to think about how focusing on one aspect of something necessarily does place other aspects in its shadow. Each of us as individuals focus on different ideas and value divergent aspects--especially when we are looking at websites; we are looking for different things depending on what our purpose is in coming to the site. Which brought me to a question:

2) What makes a "good" website for me? More precisely, How can I tell if a website is legit (authoritative; what I think it represents itself to be) for the purpose I am using it for? My thinking was along these lines: if websites are in a way "writing", then their rhetorical situation would seem to function similarly to that of textual writing: writing is born of an exigency,  exists to accomplish a purpose, and envisions a particular audience (Grant-Davie, Rhetorical Situations).

Maybe I am completely off here, but what I hear Covino and Jolliffe's saying that "text" is built up of signifiers--which is troubling when looking for legitimacy, because for me to make the call on what is legitimate multimodal writing for my purposes, I must apply the principles of rhetorical situations. And everything I see in a rhetorical situation is made up of my own perceptions: who I am and what I'm about dictates what signifiers I ever recognize to begin with. By focusing on those, I obscure the others, and when writing for others, especially for a grade, who knows if my and the instructor's grading signifiers (for what something means) will sync?

This process of certain things signifying (meaning) something to me is all well and good when I am just looking for entertainment: I just surf the web and stop on things that make me laugh. There isn't a conscious evaluation of what I'm basing my entertainment-value judgments on, even though I'd bet the mental process is similar to the one I go through for scholarly texts. But what about when I am doing research and am looking for seriously trustworthy data? I've been through the process of attempting to judge what texts are scholarly and belong in my work, but how do I accomplish that decision on multimodal websites? Is there a certain look that makes me believe a site is worth my time? A sound?


What instantly comes to mind in light of the above, is that it would be tremendously helpful to know what signifiers my audience (often a professor, if the context is school papers) keys in on and sees as legit. But aside from that, it seems valuable to me to look inward and ask myself in a very practical way, "What signifiers (of legitimacy) do I look for in multimodal writing? If what I naturally tend to value obscures other ways of seeing and knowing, I might wanna know that so I can at least be conscious of what I might be focusing on, and what I might be missing by doing that. This led me to my third point--something I did not know (and am not super excited about, because it very much dates me, I suppose).

3) When my purpose is scholarly writing and I want texts to cite, I default to trusting singularly textual writing as being more valid than anything multimodal. I'd guess this is due to being raised in an era whose culture conveyed several things to me: Prior to easy Internet access and an upsurge in self-publishing, books were automatically legit. If it was published, it just had to be valid, and made up of data/information that could be trusted. In my experience, a book was an authority. Which went a long way to influence my thinking that texts were authoritative and legitimate--just because they were texts. Even when books were for entertainment, they obviously had to go through a rigorous process to get published, so they carried with them a very strong ethos of "being of quality". The mindset I grew up with (And I be curious if I'm the only one) was that research or any seriously important work was done via texts, and anything video/audio (so, multimodal, though I don't think the word was used then) was for entertainment. The farther I go on in my education, the more open I find myself to other modes of writing other than text as being useful for research, interaction, and data collection. It is a brave new world (and I sound so other than this digital generation, even though I am loving technology as I learn how to use it!).

Rhetorical Situation: I expect the digital resource to fit  the expected ethos of who/what it represents. For example, if I'm looking for a history of the church, I don't expect Playboy Bunnies scattered throughout the site--if they were, then I'd probably think twice before taking the site's "writing" seriously (because of an unfitting context, not an objection to content). Conversely, If I were documenting the rise of the Playboy kingdom, and wanted to hear about it from the those who built it, I'd hesitate to take a Bible-thumping rendition of the story as fact. =) I don't expect a Disneyland website  to look serious or somber, and I don't expect College English to have happy, colorful fairies flitting around it.

5) One other thing I noted (that might not be the best way to think, but it is a way I noticed that I default to decision making on the validity of a digital source for whatever my project): I tend to think of people as having somewhat of a brain to have thought about who would use their site. It doesn't always hold true, but overall, I seem to note that the websites that are geared for public use and entertainment are usually more (or less) user-friendly. The more specialized the multimodal writing, the more even using it seems to require some specific knowledge. Like this one, where it is clear that it has absolutely something to do with astronomy. It looks so neat. It seems like I could do something really smart with it. Analyze to my heart's content. If I just knew exactly what it applied to and how to make use of it. And I'm sure I could figure it out, but I don't have that kind of time (I have small children).

Wrong or right, (and all other ways I would judge the validity of a website aside--like the address--that's always a good starting place), the kind of knowledge that seems required for use of this astronomy website (the link above) is the kind professionals in that field would use. As Covino and Jolliffe say, that is a signifier for me, and in focusing on that, I do obscure other aspects of the page: for instance, once I've decided this site is for specialists, if I notice an interface that just seems unhelpful to me, I'll more likely think that it is just beyond my knowledge level, whereas if I were looking at a more for-public, entertainment site and noted the same annoying, unhelpful features, I'd just think it was bad web design.

Anyway, wow! So much rhetoric going on in multimodal writing situations. I had no idea. Very cool. But you know what I wonder? Will paper texts ever become obsolete? Can we become such people of the multimodal that mere letters on a screen won't do, and we need animation? I've heard arguments for and against, but nobody has ever given me a reason why or why not that makes sense to me. Got one?

4 comments:

  1. Oh Angie, I hope to God paper texts never become obsolete. Not sure I want to live in that kind of world...
    If we become a people that insists on animation to hold our interest, what would become of the imagination??? I fear that day. The theatre of the mind is a powerful place, and I am afraid it will vanish if we are not left to create images in our heads while reading.
    I will not ever 'get over' the need to hold a book in my hands. I don't want to get over it.
    I LOVE books. That's my two cents. I'm sure I am considered to be an old phogey.
    And yes, I will be printing the articles for our class. Just can't do the screen-reading very effectively.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. It is really weird, Angie. Simply because these are the exact same issues that are arising in my autobiography/memoir class. While signifiers and exigence are not specifically addressed, the class does raise similar issues about language and rhetoric that both grant-davie and Covino and jollife are raising. Are we in control of the language or is the language in control of us? How much of the rhetoric is conveying to both the author and reader (aka rhetor and audience) without them even realizing it? These questions and the more questions that arise are just enough to make your head spin.

    By the way, for some reason this damn website doesn't recognize me and can't post my name when I leave a comment, so this is Spencer Kirkemo: signing off.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The signifier/signified thing is quite a conundrum. I had to drop a Hispanic Poetry class this semester because the teacher seemed to think that poems could only be interpreted one way (his way) and I was not down with that. It was sad to drop it, because before meeting the teacher I was really excited, even though I'd heard bad things about him, but I love poetry. So in the end it wasn't worth ruining something I love because our signifier/signified ideas clashed.

    Anyway, I don't think paper texts will ever go out of style. I will boycott the Kindle and the iPad to ensure this.

    ReplyDelete