Tuesday, September 27, 2011

The Technology Elevates the Need to be Context-Conscious

I've been thinking the past few days about context, and how the importance of building and expressing (or at least recognizing) context increases with the multimodal ways we have to interact. Let me see if I can explain that a little better.

I was an avid pen-pal when I was growing up--I had pen-pals I'd never met, friends I'd only met once in person then we went on to have rich relationships as we grew up--separated by miles and sometimes international borders, but deeply connected all the same. Both my grandmas, an aunt and uncle traveling around the world in the military, and two widowed great-aunts were among the regular writers. For the majority of my upbringing, writing and receiving letters was the equivalent of what I use today: email, chat, FaceBook, texting, YouTube, and telephone. When I think of letters as one mode of writing/communication (as alphabetic text, and sometimes including drawings or dried flowers), I think of context as being fairly easy to shape: the letter was to one person, from one person, and the context that shaped the letter was the relationship and what each person was going through in their lives right then. That is the simplicity I see now as I look back, anyway. When I was in the situation, I remember agonizing over how little I knew someone in the first year of writing, and trying very hard to find a balance between what I'd like to say and express, and what I thought might interest, inspire and be relateable-to by them. I didn't know it, but I was searching for context. And as I said, I think context then was slightly simpler, because I feel like the context lived a life that was shaped by the relationship, and when letters take 7 days to get somewhere and no other communication is used, relationships change slower--I feel.

Fast forward to now. The sheer immediacy of texting and chatting does something to the nature of context. For example, there are some people who have an experience that is horrible, and before even attempting to handle the situation or internally process it, they'll text, post it on FaceBook, or shoot out an email. For me as the reader, context here depends on prior knowledge of the temperament of the person: if so-and-so thinks they're dying and it's the end of the world, I might chuckle and not reply for a couple days until they've had a chance to process their drama and realize it was really nothing--they just like creating reality TV wherever they go. Now for others who rarely share personal feelings or show emotion in our various ways of communication, even a little hint that something is wrong gets more attention from me, because it is so unusual that it probably signifies something much bigger is wrong.

My point is that the time and situatedness of our multimodal means of interaction calls for a greater understanding of the rhetors (speakers/senders of messages) who are sending the message, for one, because the real-life time we communicate in is dynamic and shifting. When you write a letter the old fashioned way, and have no other means of more immediate communication, the tool, or the technology (as Baron so intriguingly talked about it) demands more thoughtfulness and reflection: you  must sit down, think, and slowly pen words onto paper. Then if you missed the postman, you have to let that letter sit overnight, and if you're like me, you'll ponder what you wrote. Much more crafting goes into that kind of communication, and it's delayed in other ways: you have to wait for the other person to write back--in that time you wonder what they thought of what you said and what they will say in return. The nature of the technology creates that.

Conversely, in this day and age, we are communicating in real time, but not face to face. We have the ability to run our mouth, our hearts, our minds, at real-life speed, and without the thoughtfulness that being there in person might create. So consciousness of context in this age require us to look at impulsiveness and temperament. Context-consciousness also asks that we think about situations: when we send an important message and don't receive one of equal weight, what was going on at the other end? Did the receiver of the message get partway through it at work, have something they had to handle, then their chat disconnected and didn't show they never finished reading the message? Maybe their phone doesn't save texts, so once they read practically and get distracted, they have no way of re-reading, and not a reminder to respond. Or what if you send a particularly kind message and get what seems like a curt one ins response, when you thought everything in the relationship was fine? Before assuming something's wrong in the relationship, the other players in the context might be considered: maybe the persons boss just started yelling at them. Maybe an ejection seat they were trying to fix got dropped from an airplane and all hell broke loose, so your "I love you" wasn't a priority at the moment.

The real-time and total access interaction capabilities we have these days  change the way we need to be thinking about context in order to communicate in accordance with our purpose. And maybe the most difficult aspect of this is that so much of the context is made up of parts you cannot know, as we are separated by space, and busy communicating in 10 different ways at once. I don't think the modern multimodal forms of communication are bad, just that, if we want to maintain healthy relationships, we need to think more deeply about the implications of contexts, and how complex they are compared to the letters I used to write as a teenager.

3 comments:

  1. Ang, I love that you said 'real time but not face to face'. It's true, we do communicate instantly and it does change the way relationships work. And I think even the curt text response to "I love you" is an important part of relationships today: it makes it more difficult to respond in an adult manner when most of the time in that context a response is not the best way to further a relationship... I don't know if I said that the best way but I mean to say that you bring up really interesting points -- hand in hand, the 7 days it takes a letter to make it around the world makes what a person writes, pencil and paper, a little more risky -- your opinion may actually have changed several times before the content of the letter is read and then the reader responds to an "outdated" idea (of sorts). So it has to be more calculated, maybe? While we can literally share our opinions *as they change*, real-time. I do love technology but I think it important to understand the conversation and appropriate discourse of the previous forms of technology. The discourse of situated technology -- sounds like a hellofa research paper haha

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Great post! The lack of thoughtfulness, eloquence, passion, and gravity of our current T9-constructed instant messages is a bit shocking when compared to the laborious, heartfelt letter writing process. Our internal "filters" - the 'think before you talk' mechanism that dictates almost all aspects of our communication to some degree - are set on low in today's age of communicative spontaneity. I commonly receive text messages that are literally incoherent. People spew bullshit from their brains to their fingertips and hit send without a second thought. I'm glad you brought up the point of people "status updating" on facebook. Its as if people want to live in the mainstream corporately scripted reality show fantasy lands that our culture is addicted to. Their version of a "confessional", except broadcast to a list of hundreds of their "friends" - 98% of them couldn't care less.

    This is of course aggravated by our decreasing intelligences (idiocracy) and a cultural shift in the way eloquence and intelligence is valued. Sounding smart isn't "cool". We insert "like" before statements in order to avoid sounding like a know it all. It's all a bit tragic if you ask me.

    Is this a technology problem? Or a deeply rooted cultural issue? While these new instantaneous forms of communication have plenty of positive implications, I believe that we are abusing them.

    ReplyDelete