Before I can write about what I'm supposed to write about, I have to ask y'all something very blunt, but I think very important--so important it has distracted me for the past half hour while I was otherwise arguing with Mishra. Anyway, the question (Not meaning any class in particular, but any/all classes in general): why do you think it is that, even when students have serious concerns about their papers, grades, and etc, most will not bring themselves to talk to their professors? Are professors scary? If so, why?
The above is merely a personal curiosity/frustration, by the way--I want to be a writing professor and before I become "one of those scary people", I wanna know why, at least, I will no longer be okay to talk to when I take the title. It frustrates me that, even some of the most serious students I know, who care very much about succeeding, still cannot bring themselves to talk to their professors--especially when its most important--like when they don't understand why a grade was low, or they think something is unfair, or that a prof has contradicted themselves or misunderstood the student. And it frustrates me worse to hear rumors that professors have no idea why this happens either--and they think themselves to be very *not* scary. Actually, come to think of it, I know serious students who want to say nice things to their profs or thank them, and they are not comfortable with even that, so I don't think it's merely the uncomfortably of disagreement that prevents student/professor interaction. Just my thoughts though--what do you think?
On to the assignment...
I find myself endlessly arguing with Mishra. I think I think I see the point--maybe. But as one student, I feel like the author's argument assumes me to be stupid. Not purposefully, of course, but I come away with that sense, a bit.
For example, on pg 147 the author (whose gender I am So clueless about due to not ever having heard that first name or knowing how to pronounce it. Yikes!) talks about how textbooks can confuse students because the diagrams (of a heart, for instance) show the veins and arteries as different colors, then when the student actually gets lab time and cuts into a heart, they are confused because the heart isn't neatly rainbow colored like the diagram. Really?? I take the point: there is hidden messages in pictures just like there is in writing, and we writers need to value that (Where's Waldo?). But sersiously? A student who fails to realize that the real thing is different than the neatly rainbow colored digram shouldn't even be holding a knife in a lab to begin with. Need we also add warnings to textbooks that say, in an annoyingly fast voice so as to implicate no importance, "Danger, the heart beats and the blood flows, and if you cut it open you will kill it. Void where prohibited. Use only as directed. Fees and charges may apply."?
If students haven't noticed, we have been diagramming things partially, and with neat little colors, so that we can understand the parts of a whole that are not evident by looking at the whole. Case in point: I went through school to learn the environmental control systems (ECS) of jet aircraft. Basically, it shows you how you take extremely hot air from the 10th or 14th stage of a jet engine and cool it partially to de-ice the wings/tail, or cool it completely (to a temperature so cold it will crack the windsceen if you turn it full cold in a hot climate--bad design but bad-ass cooling system!) to keep the avionics cool. In school, they handed us bad-ass Sailors a blank diagram of the ECS system and made us color it: very hot air: red. Warm air: Orange. Cold air: blue. Really important thing to remember: All the valves on the red lines fail in a closed position. Do you think that when I got up on my first aircraft wing, took off the panel and began troubleshooting the gripe that I was looking for red, orange or blue ducting? Of course not! But do you know, I was, very much, tracing all the metal ducting that looked so much alike in real life, and recalling the diagram in my head, reminding myself which duct should be very hot, and which cold, by that which valve would fail closed. And so when I came to a duct that would have been red on the diagram and it was cold during operation, I knew I had a valve failed shut--and I knew where to start looking for my failed sensor, actuator, or valve.
Maybe I sorely missed where the author points this out, but I feel, if there is a fault with such "unrealistic" diagrams and pictures, it is not in them existing in the first place, but in the textbooks/instructors lack of pointing out that to study things, we often stop their motion and break them down into tiny peices so we can understand them. That helps. That works--I feel. But we need also to be reminded that these stopped pictures are just representations, and they go back into motion into a dynamic activity that is not neatly color-coded and functioning according to textbook. Everybody knows when you take something apart, it stops working, and then 1) you must put it back together again, and 2) it had to be op-checked (turned on, put back in motion) to see if it was put back together right. I don't care how non-mechanically inclined you are, if something gets stuck in your vacuum so the roller stops turning, you turn it off, pick out the hari, yarn and whatever, and then turn it back on. Common sense. yet we forget to apply this principle to learning: if you stopped it to study it, you have to put it back in motion to finish studying it. If you took it apart to see a piece of it, you must put it back together to see the whole.
A further point I was thinking here is that the kind of colored diagrams the author mentions help us show activity and motion in a picture which otherwise looks very still. We need that. And I return to the point of being considered, as a student, unable to note the difference between a coloring project and real life: I am a rhetorical being. I look for hidden meaning. So do you (I believe, even if we all are not conscious that we do). we are conscious of more than just the literal. So, yes, more attention apparently needs to be paid by research to looking at art/pictures/diagrams/visual literacy rhetorically, but I feel like as humans, we already "read" visuals like that. Where I feel I need the help is in learning how to "write" visually. It is more difficult for me to know what picture gets across what message than it is for me to "read" the messages other put in their compositions.
As long as we are looking at pictures and digram rhetorically, realizing, as the author says somehere else, that they have histories and pasts as well, we are okay. Of course a picture is rhetorical! What else could it be???
I am greatly looking forward to discussing Mishra in class, because there were a great number of times I marked question marks in the margins, wanting to see more than the rant I have here :-).
On the topic of professors......
ReplyDeleteIf I were to think about incentives (which I do)I would conclude that professors as a group have a fairly perverse incentive package in relation to their rolls as teachers. Pay (as an active incentive) comes in a number of distinct forms: 1)monetary compensation 2)ego/lifestyle compensation. I would find both to be perverse.
The first, monetary compensation, is not related to hours worked. Money earned is given as a predetermined salary. This works against the student because any time outside of class the professor gives to a student is an out of pocket expense. Therefor, rational professorial communication with students is likely to be hurried and without regard to student need. Secondly, this compensation is under the pretense that the professor will produce academic goods. Again time with students outside of class takes away from this goal.
The second set of compensation incentives similarly have to do with student interaction being a waste of time. Because pay in academia almost always is less than in the private sector, professors often moonlight. Student interaction doesn't aid in this endeavor. Secondly professors tend to enjoy the hours the job provides (thats why they do it in lieu of monetary compensation), again not helping the student.
Really all of the reasons I've listed are the same, professors don't get paid to care. While I don't believe in the possibility of altruism, I also acknowledge the existence of good teachers in the academic profession despite the lack of reason. This probably has to to with nebulous qualities like genuine interest in students success or something like that.
Just my thoughts.....
Great analysis!
ReplyDeleteAll of the discussion on the problems with visual aids seems to be half baked. If the emphasis was less on the productivity of an image and more on the way to improve that productivity, I would be much less scowl-ly. I've been reading blogs touting the failure of computer generation and I can't stop thinking they should start thinking! I loved the discussion in class (though it was brief) about the transformation of images in to specialized code. Schematics for example (my nemesis) are textual in that specific, non interpretive information is given without non-useful information. Readers are not free to interpret (creatively) what the author wrote/drew.
Anyways totally spot on as usual, thanks for the post!
Interesting description of your time evaluating jet engines.
ReplyDeleteRegarding the teacher/student issue, I have thought about this too. When I attended MSU 30 years ago, it would have been difficult for me to talk to a professor about anything negative. I was too un-supposing, too shy, too concerned about saying the wrong thing. Menopause changes all that...ha ha. Seriously. As a woman ages, there is a shift. We go from always being concerned about making things nice for others, to just needing to speak the truth plainly. There's a definite shift. I think the hesitance to speak to professors is rooted in our uncertainty. When I came back to school, I felt the same insecurity, only now it was about being an older student. Would I fit, would people think I was weird for being in school at my age. It took a bit of adjustment, but after a few months, I felt grounded again. I love to talk to professors about things, both positive and negative. But it took many years to get to the place where I was comfortable enough with myself to do that.
Regarding what picture gets across what message--I think that is part of the visual literacy that needs to be taught. So the question is, will the powers that be ever validate that need?
As a future professor, I really don't see you being the type that students would be too scared to see. I know that a lot of students like me are just simply too busy to just find the time to talk to professors whenever we have trouble, whether it is catching up on homework or doing a part time job or both. Usually right after class I have to go to work for five hours and have to catch up on homework sometime between nine and ten o'clock at night. Just some food for thought on your future career =).
ReplyDeleteI've been thinking about your "Why don't students talk to their professors?" question, and I have to agree with Spencer that often it's just for lack of time. I usually like my professors (when I don't like one, I'll never go see him during office hours, because it's hard enough sitting through his class...and yes the only professor I currently don't like is a man), but even when I like a professor and wouldn't mind chatting outside of class, I can't find time or justification to do so. A lot of the time the professor's office hours don't work for me, or even if they do, if I don't have a serious concern and I'm doing well in the class, I'd feel weird stopping by "just to chat" if I didn't have a real question about the class.
ReplyDelete