What I hear Kress saying here, is that, in alphabetic text, genre-mixing was once an embarrassment, ('dis is bad), but in multimodal texts, genres must, by the text's very mixed nature, be mixed and so, multimodal mixed genre writing is good (52). I guess, first off, that makes me wonder how true/widespread it is (was?) that mixed-genre writing is a negative thing--is it individual perspective, or all the turkeys in a field?
I love what Kress gets to in the end of his chapter, because based on the way he was defining genre in the beginning, I felt the same familiar frustration I get when people talk about genre's as fixed entities. My limited experience shows that, if genres are as rigid as Kress starts out intimating, writers drift in and out of genre's all the time, based upon the social interaction invited by the perspective. And that seems like too tight of a way to define genre.
Shouldn't we be able to write and represent many different social perspectives and interactions, while still remaining within a genre? Take academic writing, for example: most students describe it as being exceedingly dry and boring, but within the range of academic writers, some write in first person and include narratives that are inviting and friendly, no matter how dense the rest of the writing (the density makes it difficult reading for an outsider, even if it is not boring or dry).
Still other academic writers write in a disconnected way that just sounds so official that I feel like I shouldn't connect their writing to anything in the real world--because they are "above reality". But isn't this all considered academic writing? Alright, enough of an aside, I just haven't been stoked on rigid ideas of genre, because at this point in my education, I feel like they are unrealistic. I'm happy that multimodal writing forces open the door on mixed-genre writing. Maybe we've seen the light.
What I thought was really neat about Kress's analysis was how it opened my eyes to just how much you can see in a writer's perspective by how they write. My own initial reaction to the two writing samples (somewhat telling) was very simple: The first was personal, the second professional. The first is how I'd write the assignment if I was at home, having fun with science; the second one is how I would've written in response to a school assignment--both as a kid and maybe now (if I had to choose between the two writing samples), because I default to thinking of science as not being a friendly walk through what someone experienced, but as factual, "do X, Y, Z and you'll get the same results". I think of science, although performed by a person, like it's supposed to be impersonal-sounding and disconnected. Yeah, I'm working on that....
But I had to laugh at Kress's analysis, because I never thought of the second writing sample as representing an interaction written from the perspective of one whose world is commanded. I just thought, "this sounds more professional, more scientific". (If the shoe fits? Yikes! 'Course, this is coming from a girl who, when asked to write "professional" school papers in junior high school, adopted some mixture of old English and lawyer-speak, and thought it was how college writing would be....)
The side-effect of my reading of Kress is that I'm so intrigued by the window into personal/social interactional ideas that he draws from people's writing, that I'm going to be going around reading to find these things he draws out. It's very cool.
Last, but certainly not least, let me recount these words that were like music to my writerly ears,
"A newer way of thinking may be that within a general awareness or the range of genres, of their shapes and their contexts, speakers and writers newly make the generic forms out of available resources. This is much more "generative" notion of genre: not one where you learn the shapes of existing kinds of text along, in order to replicate them, but where you learn the generative rules of constitution of generic form within the power structures of society. And you learn what the shapes of these texts are, coming out of those social conditions. That will permit (and account for) constant change, and makes the actions of the producer of the genre innovative and transformative. It encourages and normalizes "design" of text in response to the perceived needs of the make of the text in a given environment. In such theory all acts of representation are innovative, and creativity is the normal process of representation for all" (53-54).
<Deep breath> Wait, did I just hear the chink of a writer's prison door opening? Of fetters falling to the cold, stone floor? Did I just hear that I, as a writer, am actually in charge of my writing? That creativity belongs in every genre? That I'm allowed movement, even within genre, based on context, social structure and personal exigence? (I feel that so often, we claim to be in charge of our writing--that we can write what we will--but we are not: we are tied and fettered to our ideas of "right writing"--that just maybe need some C4 applied to them...)
Whenever I see movement, I get excited, because life moves, and in the same way, I believe writing should be allowed to move--genres included. Past generations are now applauded for changes the world resisted during their time. Why are we any different? If we will remain relevant to a shifting world, I agree with Kress: we need rhetorical eyes that see why genres are structured as they are (societal why's), so that we can shift our writing powerfully to meet new social needs as they present themselves around us.
I'm also stoked on the idea of creativity and movement within genres. And it's true that we need what you call "rhetorical eyes" to apply that creativity well. It all goes back to what I think in every Lit class I take..."I don't know anything about history." I almost think that all English majors should double major in History so we know what really happened. But anyway, in the present tense that means reading the news and stuff, and knowing what other people are thinking and doing, in order to communicate with them most effectively. And the most effective way to do that is to keep ideology out of it. (Which is now my new excuse for not getting involved in politics).
ReplyDeleteWhat Kress talked about seemed to be the exact opposite of what and how Jakobs presented his ideas and research. He had the exact academic writing style that we are all complaining about and it really frustrated the hell out of me. I really didn't get into that article. I liked his ideas but I didn't like how he presented them.
ReplyDelete