First of all, I must say that I feel lucky to have homework that is just reading comics--or I did, until I was actually reading something very much like scholarly research, written in a different tone, with different font, enclosed in speech blurb-thingy's (these must have a name I should look up...) and narrated by some dude with no eyes, nice glasses and a lightning bolt on his shirt (that should mean something to me, I feel, but doesn't). I found myself feeling slightly let down, because the look of the chapter made me expect to laugh--and I didn't. I did come to some neat light bulb sorta moments, and I got tired of reading on screen (I didn't have the ink reserves to print this!) black and white font and pictures that are somehow more eye-tiring than just text. And yet, despite what sounds like bitching, but is really just my narrating of my homework-reading-expectations, I paid more attention than I would have if this were 3 chapters of deep scholarly thought-on-paper in the usual form.
Why? Is it culture? Am I conditioned to think that anything that comes to me in comic form is easy reading and enjoyable? Does it have to do with what McCloud actually points out: that the iconic nature of the lesser amount of details in the the form enables me to put myself into the script more than I would if it were just alphabetic text? At least one answer might be that I think, in some way, I expect to be able to relate to a comic--no matter what--whereas if something is merely alphabetic text, then who knows if I will relate and understand or not. Expectations based upon personal norms, maybe.
Up until this past month, I had never personally recognized the value I assign to different fonts. I knew some were more relaxed and "pretty", but I never seriously thought that one could have an impact on me over another towards a certain end, or in a persuasive way. In the (hopefully-one-day-published) book chapter that I just finished co-writing with Doug, I was constantly struggling with the idea that I had equal voice in the project, even though, because of the subject matter (military veterans in writing courses), as the military veteran, I had to maintain a "co-learner" rather than "follower" attitude. In my head I knew I had the role and the voice of a co-author, but it was a hard thing to believe and carry out into my tone as I was writing. I found myself struggling particularly bad one day and realized that I was writing all my drafts in Times New Roman, and they felt like a school assignment. When the "feel" of the document was "assignment", it reinforced the idea that I didn't (or shouldn't or couldn't) have an equal voice in our research and writing. So I changed my font to one I never use--one that had never ever represented an assignment to me. And ya know what? it helped.
That is just wild to me--because even though I am creative, when I write I'm usually thinking about the beauty of the idea and the words themselves, not at all any "meaning" or "persuasiveness" that the font itself could portray. And yet, in the heat of the battle that is writing, I was grasping for ways to not feel like a student when I was writing in a more non-student-ish role, and I instinctively changed the only thing I had control over: the font that screamed "student" to me. Until that moment, I didn't know fonts even had voices, much yet screamed with them! =)
Anyway, I am still kinda marveling over font having powers of persuasion, and all this comic reading impacted me the same way. I keep wondering, if we took any of our other scholarly articles and put them in comics form, would they be easier to read? ALOT easier to read? Less boring (If they were boring to begin with)? And further, can comics even hold the language that is wrapped up in scholarly writing, or would the comic cease to be, well, ya know, comic-y? (By the way, have I ever said how annoyed I get with hyperlinks? I don't want to stop reading, jump through time and space to get distracted by something else, but if I don't, will I be missing half the context???)
Angie, I always love reading your rhetoric and getting a sense of your perspective in the world. That being said, I am once again struck by your unapologetic and no-nonsense dialogues on the message you want to convey and how you convey it.
ReplyDeleteEver since college, my writing has always screamed at me "suck-up student." I am very willing to believe that many students feel your anguish whenever we try to remain true to our own perspecitives about our world and our education and at the same time conveying what the system itself wants from us.
Side note: I actually think it would be much better if most (if not all) academic texts were translated into comic book form: I actually had incentive to keep reading our assigned texts for class simply because it wasn't a dry, boring rambling from an academic who thought his/her subject of interest was going to hell (please don't punish me Dr. Downs)=)
You didn't laugh??? I laughed at least six times, out loud. Yeah, I LOL'd. Maybe just because of the semi-delirious state I was in when I read it. Do you hear what I'm saying? If you do, have your ears checked, because no one said a word.
ReplyDeleteThe font thing is so true. I do all of my non-academic writing in Arial, even though it's still a standard font, it's no Times New Roman, and it makes me feel more like a human.
The parts of the comic that I found most intriguing were the plain boxes, with only the glasses-man and his speech bubble. At one point there were three in a row, and I thought, he could have just made that one big speech bubble and grouped it all into one frame, but he didn't. Why? So we focus on each sentence that much more? Maybe, I don't know, but it worked.
Love that you draw on your personal life to connect with the text. I have a website that might help you when you're writing for the hell of it. It's darkcopy.com, and it gives you a black background and a green text in a relaxed font, so you aren't distracted from your writing by the means in which you are writing it.
ReplyDeleteAlso, I looked up the speech bubble thing. Couldn't find any more scientific-like word than balloon, though.