Wednesday, September 14, 2011

Internal Necessity of Being: Literacy as Connection

I know I'm an odd duck. I've learned to accept it. And wonder if I would be who I am if I wasn't initially raised by some very Victorian English-Scott's-women who read chapters and chapters of un-understandable old-English, thought God only spoke in "Thou's" and "Shouldst's" and never dreamed of praying a prayer that wasn't already written somewhere. Their arthritic fingers flew as they skillfully played classical music on an heirloom piano that has been in our family, probably since Captain Lyon piloted the ship over from England to the New World in 1640 that held a boatload (literally) of my ancestors who, generations prior to arriving here were (allegedly) asked to come to England to help drive out some French folks, and as a reward were then given a town called Lyon--hence the name. (Then there's the pride that not one, but two strains of Lyon blood flows through the Queen of England's veins...not that it's helped our family any--or Cousin Lizzy herself either, but I digress, and must apologize: the Queen does so hate it when we call her "Lizzy"...)

But you get the point. My grandma and her mom (born in 1889) flat out revered written text. It was a world where the more complicated it was, the more valuable it was--and that applied to reading, writing, music, food and even oral storytelling (they never came up with a simple solution to a simple life problem either--these were some complex folks--not a shock, since they were devoutly devoted to a Diety who would seem not-Diety-ish if his words were written without all the "-ests" and "-eth's" on them. Good = complex). To this day my grandma refuses to use email, with a turned-up aire that says, "All this technology is not good for us." Not surprisingly, then, for years and years of my reading-saturated life, I was a reading snob. I could recite entire lengthy paragraphs from memory after just a read or two, savoring the flavor of each word. I didn't know any other way to be, and also be wise and educated like these women who were the foundation of my association with literacy and text. And I've been an outsider to a world that struggles with reading ever since. I'm not sure I realized that love of reading is a temperament thing until this past year, and now I feel bad that I was a reading snob.

These lines from Jacobs melted my soul, and I breathed in the naming of a part of me so deep that I cannot even analyze it myself, "I am not sure deep attention to anything in particular can be taught in a straightforward way: it may, perhaps, only arise from within, according to some inexplicable internal necessity of being." That resonates with me because I was always the one trying to look deeply into a well when others saw only the surface reflecting the sky. There is something beautiful in realizing temperament traits and just being what comes naturally.  So why do we have to point to those who can't bear to read as if they are worse, or somehow less evolved beings? Are those who digest their information via video less literate? My grandma's would have thought so. But then, let's look at the context of their lives.


I'm older than most in this class--both of my grandmothers were born in the 1920's and have vivid memories of the Great Depression. They lived difficult, meager lives. Back then, print was what connected them to their world. Text was their internet, their laptops, their blogs, their cell phones. Imagine being young and in love and having your husband go off to war, and waiting for news of his world in newspapers or letters from him. Newspapers wer devoured as a family affair in the evening--the only connection to a far-away place once so surreal and now containing the one treasure my grandmas helds dearer than life: her man. The only way they have to share life and stay connected is via texts (writing, not cell phone texts!). And so today, my other grandma watches TV and talks on the phone, but both of my grandmas get the most deeply involved in their books. You can see them get comfortable and cozy when they get in their little reading places and prepare to visit a land far away, hidden in the pages. If we speak in terms of multimodalities, these women had only two for most of their formative years: talking in person, and written texts. These are languages they speak--or, if you'll allow me the indulgence--these were, and still mostly are, their literacies.

I've come to some interesting and wild (to me) thoughts tonight that had never occurred to me before: go here with me for a second--I dare you. Let's take a stab at redefining literacy (because notice, if we in 371 are going to accept the definition of "writing" as being done in any medium, then don't we also have to redefine "literacy"???). Say, just for a scary second, that literacy has nothing to do with "reading a text" in the traditional sense that we have known it. Pretend that literacy must have something to do with being fluent in different kinds of interactions, and the degree of literacy is now going to be gauged against the norms for people who speak or interact in that literacy, or language. This could be reasonable, right? It would have to be, in my thinking, because we now have so many modes of writing that no one seems to be fluent in speaking/reading/writing all of them. And if we take away the idea that written texts are supreme, then what we have left is not literacy and illiteracy, but different ways of interacting, and people who are fluent at some and not at others, right? (Now don't hang me just yet, I know the precious text-literacy is a hot topic here, but use some logic for a minute, rather than the printed-text-passion that I also share with you.)

What is the point, I ask you, of alllllllll these multimodal ways of writing? Is it not connection? Isn't it true that any media we use, we use interactively? And if yes interactively, then yes, for connection: we connect to ideas and those who share similar ideas via multimodal writing. Faith, humor, learning, love, sorrow, information, work--all these things we connect around. And don't we use the media/medium (or mode) that is the most comfortable to us? We may claim that we are using the most appropriate one or the most highly esteemed one, but really, we are merely using the one or two that are the most comfortable for us, right? I think we established this in our wonderful discussion in class on Tuesday, so can we move on exploring my insane idea for a minute?

My grandma's only had one mode (other than in person) to connect to others with: alphabetic, printed text. There was nothing else. And think how long that was true in history before the invention of the radio, and TV, and then computers and internet. We've said in class that writing is only good if it accomplishes it's purpose, and I'd say any mode of writing is the same way. While an individual purpose for a blog might be to fulfill a class assignment, what it ultimately does is connect the members of this class, right? Whatever else a text (of any mode) is doing, it is ever and always connecting. And we are here, reading, writing, and learning because we are creatures who long to connect. Remember in the Virtual Choir video how Eric Whitacre says, "Human beings will go to any lengths necessary to find and connect with each other; it doesn't matter the technology."?  And then a bit later he describes those who contributed to his project as, "Souls, all on their own desert islands, sort of sending electronic messages in bottles to each other." Doesn't that sound a lot like the generation of World War II, waiting eagerly for the newspaper, and by the mailbox, for any message in a bottle for their desert island?

I submit for your review an idea new (and very welcome) to me: literacy is not really about learning, per-say; literacy is a modern day and acceptable word for the human desire to be connected (Or maybe "literacy" describes the way in which we are able to fulfill that need). For years and years text was the only way to connect beyond face to face conversation and walking distance (unless you spoke smoke-signal, and that just gets difficult). It isn't any more. We can connect in ways that fit our temperaments, and appeal whatever is our individual sense of home, safe, snug and happy, like my grandmas get when they read. Other generations didn't have that, so, whether it suited their temperament or not, they did everything they possibly could to become literate, and so be able to connect the only way they could: via alphabetic, printed texts. Just because I'd rather spend all day in my bean-bag chair absorbing chapters of Harry Potter, rather than watching movies or making YouTube videos, why should that make me more literate and better than someone who can read enough to get by, but changes lives by their ability to connect in electronic ways? It shouldn't. It seems to me that those who would argue for the sacredness of single-mode, printed texts are still falling for a thinly veneered grade-school argument over who is better than the others.

The object of the game was always the transference of ideas, and the connecting of people--we have hundreds of ways to do that now, and no moral or ethical reason I can see to claim that one is "holier than thou". However, we each do have, as Jacobs said so beautifully, "an internal necessity of being", both to connect and how to go about that connecting. What is your "internal necessity of being"? Go with it. Be brave with it, fluent in it, and prolific with it. Build your dreams, one text at a time--whatever mode that text might be. With your work motivate me to be literate in another mode of connecting, 'cause who knows what other modes I might love, and not even know about now, right? Literacy is such a horrible word to me, because it seems it's always used around a sense of lack: illiteracy . If we open our eyes and be willing to see differently, maybe we see a world full of beautiful and diverse literacy--literacy we could all benefit from, if we just would be willing to discover new ways to meaningfully connect.

Pardon me while I go hunt down and apologize to anyone I ever turned up my nose at for not loving to read like I do....

2 comments:

  1. Nice ideas and expansion of those ideas, Angie. I was forced, in my child rearing years, to re-evaluate my uppity ideas about reading. Though it has always been my way of connecting, and learning, some of my children are very different from me. I had to see and honor that difference, or be in constant conflict. It has taken me awhile to realize that people(and the way they learn) are as varied and unique as the drops of water on your screen, and that's okay.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Fantastic post, Angie. New ideas for me. Well played.

    ReplyDelete