I found Wysocki intensely riveting, even at a time when I had a minimal attention span (Normally 27 pages daunts me, but I read it on two layovers and during two flights, and pondered what in the world the outcome might be for 24 hours once I got home with still 3 pages left to read). I think part of the intrigue was that I had no idea where she was going with the whole thing. (I'm not sure I do after finishing it, either! But I'd like to read it again, and because I probably won't get to that, I'm hoping we have lively discussion on it in class.) I also somehow managed to not realize the author was a woman until the last 3 pages, so another part of the intrigue was wondering how a male was going to pull off a scholarly article that focused on a woman's ass, and in the end, it not be weird!
I want to say a little about what I do think I understood of what Wysocki had to say. I hear her saying that we have been unwittingly trained to design with the purpose of grabbing and holding the attention of "readers", but that is shallow thinking. I hear her saying that if we would write rhetorically--in our design--we should be writing--or designing--in a way that creates interaction. Anyone know how to do that? Because I know a little of how to create interaction with words, but with design? I'm stumped.
I'm even more disturbed to find that I didn't even realize it, but I totally had learned, somewhere along the line, that a good graphic grabs people's attention, not a good graphic produces interaction. But wait, I'm confused--because when it comes to advertising, the same inner needs and desires that stop viewers/readers and cause them to look at something, if effective enough, often motivates them to buy the product as well. In that way, I see the attention grabbing and the interaction-causing as being different stages of action caused by the same design. But I tire easily of the advertising aspect of it, because in talking about that we so easily drift back to talking about rhetoric as if it is no more than a cheap trick to get people to buy stuff.
Is there another way we can talk about design creating interaction? No, not religion. Not advertising. Where else is there meaningful design whose goal is not merely a reaction, but an interaction? I'm sure they are everywhere, but I'm drawing a blank, at the moment. Thoughts? And further, I can imagine creating graphics that make people angry so they would respond, but that is easy--and not an interest of mine. What sort of design draws out building, meaningful interactions?
I'm curious what y'all thought when you saw the Peek ad (some of you, anyway, others of you might refrain from sharing...;-) For me, I learned that I don't know that I have the capability to separate form from content anyway. Before I ever figured out what the article was about, I noted the Peek ad and actually thought it was accidentally included in this article (reading online, on a small screen, and in a hurry at first--I skipped the picture trying to connect the rest of the texts' thoughts). But you know what I saw as I breezed by the picture? Intense vulnerability--and not in a positive, intimate way. This is a gross generalization, I know, but in my experience, women don't pose like that unless it is for another. I sense an abject lack-of-self in the woman portrayed in this picture--she is being what she has been convinced is beauty for some reason she is convinced is important--a reason that, if she knew she had other value, wouldn't hold water. Beauty? Maybe. But I saw misery there.
Here are some examples that I thought of for text interaction:
ReplyDelete1)Graffiti. I always see graffiti as a form of advertisement or street sign that one is supposed to interact with. One can either literally graffiti over it or one can think or act upon the message it evokes. The stop signs with "war", "running me", or "Bush" may be all too generic, but damn they're funny and I remember where they are on a street. It's at the very least a small sticky note that's directly in my line of sight. Not many authors can grab that kind of attention.
2)Reader mail: In some ways, blogs and comments already serve this conversation, but what really sticks out are the letters to the editor. Columns such as 'Dear Abby' and countless sports columnists have a conversation as part of the text. It spurs other readers to write in and allows them a voice to agree or disagree.
Ha. I actually assumed it was a woman right away, because I figured there was no way a man would be angered by that ad.
ReplyDeleteI did the same as you, scrolling past the picture to continue reading the text. I feel that I've grown so accustomed to advertising done in that manner that I can ignore it. The idea has been done, it isn't interesting anymore.
It is tough to say where we can interact with human experience and design, simply because we always seem to react and interact with media, technology, practicually anything. We use technology to fulfill our personal desires (washing dishes, cleaning messes, turning lights on), we turn on the news in the hopes that we will become better informed of the world (although it is very unlikely that happens with today's news) and we always look for ways to feel complete, whole, and entertained with what we surround ourselves with (TV, Computer, Lamps,etc.) I wrote down too many etc's didn't I? Anyway's, our world just becomes more complicated with what we produce and how we interact with it.
ReplyDeleteLike you, I thought the ad was incidental as well. I kept turning the page, mildly annoyed that it was still there. I'm a little slow on the uptake...
ReplyDeleteI have known young women who played this role of model, exotic dancer, etc. Never have I seen it be a fulfilling or life-building thing. There is something sad about being seen as body parts, literally. The human spirit is demeaned by this view. There may be some who claim it is great and a good life. I'm not buying. Why then are drugs such a large part of this life? I'd need to be numb if I were that divided too.
Regarding your question: I find that blogging with the use of pictures creates interaction. People usually respond to the photos.
I also thought the ad was an accident and skipped right past it until she started talking about it on the next page haha then I went back and looked at the add more thoroughly. Though I do have to say that I wasn't as taken aback by or offended by the ad though. Although, I think perhaps four years ago I would be in your same boat of feeling that the woman was in pain or sorrowful.
ReplyDeleteI would say that the image of the woman is a really effective ad in many cases. I often am drawn to ads that even use the line of the silhouette of a woman (tampons, hair products, books, etc). Though the image can never capture the depth of any single human, it certainly does great things for the beauty of the ad itself and draws the onlooker in. I don't mean to give the impression that I'm "pro-porn" or anything like that. I've taken quite the stance against the exploitation of women in my life but I am beginning to realize the value of the beauty of physical forms of any appearance in the human mind and spirit: it is all about the physical, spiritual and mental dance.
Anyway -- as far as images and texts and layout, I think it makes a very subtle but important impact on the reader and the piece to have an appealing layout, including images.And I'm pretty sure that even in advertising that interaction is key. Regardless of whether someone will purchase the product, effective advertising will force the person, upon hearing the company name, recall the ad. That is pretty intense marketing (like, my nieces sing the "We are farmers, bumbadumbumbumbumbum!" ad) Texts and how we remember them brings up an interesting question: what makes it happen? What does it look like? We should ask Daniel Paladino (I think he designs a website for his job?)