Monday, October 24, 2011

Prisoners of the Window We Look Through

I am rather overwhelmed at the amount of interesting ideas that Landham talks about. None are new to the class--I feel they are very much what we have been discussing, but expressed in  deeper fashion.

I'm not sure I know enough about this to write smartly about it, but I'm going to attempt it--it's what I see in Landham more than anything.

He addresses the issue that multimodal writing is demanding that we redefine literacy. "Electronic technology has prompted so hostile a response from the humanities establishment because it creates a different literacy from our customary print-based one" (160). I think this is cool, because I was already wondering about that here. I feel that the present move to focus on multimodal writing, reading, and literacy creates a perfect challenge for rhetoric to gain some credibility (other than the current "All that political BS" that the world seems to view it as now).

I think Landham refers to it as chaos theory, but I think he means (or should mean!) rhetorical theory. "Whatever else it may be, the new mixture of word, image, and sound that digital communication brings with it will be radically non-linear, associative, discontinuous, interactive" (160). That sounds a lot like rhetoric to me. Rhetoric seems based in two very important concepts: 1) looking with open eyes at the way things are right now, with an eye toward their context in past and present, and 2) human interaction. To embrace either of these dynamics of rhetoric, we have to let loose the idea that things should be a certain way--enough to be able to see and work from the way they are presently. Landham's words to this are strong, "Because we have thought photographs, like 'black-and-white' words, to be unalterable talismans of truth, like long-time prisoners we shudder when our chains are removed. But all these fixities are technological conventions, not eternal truths" (157).

What I sense that Landham is getting at here is that this digital era, this multimodal writing, is challenging the very core principles that humanities education has been based in. I might be wrong, because this is fuzzy for me, but I hear Landham saying that humanities community has been built upon the assumption that form is separate from content, that "the printed page was a transparent window onto the world of thought" (157). The very invent of writing on screen challenges that concept (without a word from those who already argued its validity--it is self evident--or seems so to me), "So. We have an expressive surface which can now mix word, written and spoken, with image and music" (157). And suddenly the very literal "window" of a computer screen has shown the metaphoric "window" that is alphabetic text for what it is: a farce. How is it even logical to imagine that letters and words--both actually symbolic and themselves pictures and icons in some sense--are but a window to see thought through with no tint of their own to color the thoughts? No, The very text itself contributes to the thought it conveys, as I will show.

Since when did human beings ever have the capability to separate themselves totally from their experience and view the world in a vacuum? We are complex beings, are we not? Furthermore, our knowledge is created through experience--even if it is merely the experience of words on a page (it is not merely this, but for this argument, we won't go there), so to truly be able to see through words to the thoughts behind them, we would have to somehow forget all the knowledge we have amassed, right? That's incredulous.

Just how incredulous? Pretend that before you are two paper documents. One is preschool triple-lined paper with crayon writing--the letters are not uniform and they look very much like a kindergartner's work. It's an important thought though--it delineates the details of a home mortgage you just found out you qualify for. The other is letterhead from an important bank, and it details the same particulars of the home mortgage you just found out you qualify for. Which one do you take seriously? If you received only the one written in crayon in an envelope from said  mortgage company, would you conclude it was bad joke? Oh, so you mean you can't just ignore the text on paper? Huh. interesting.

I find it almost impossible to believe that professionals whose job is to analyze text have held the "clear container" belief to be true, but Landham says multimodality is challenging the entire paradigm: "This transparent medium was for humanism what Newtonian physics was for science--a fundamental paradigm. Pure conceptual thought, unintermediated by expression, was possible and indeed ideal. The printed page was a transparent window onto the world of thought" (157).

It seems to me that the upsurge of multimodality is asking those who see themselves as "guardians of a way of literacy or life" to wake up and see that culture has moved on. Landham notes, "...books create a natural authority: you can quarrel with them but only marginally or by writing another book" (155). With the invent of text on screen where it can be cut and pasted at will, society has fucked with what has stood as social authority for decades and, "The whole system of cultural authority we inherited from Renaissance Humanism thus evaporates, literally, at a stroke" (155). This must be a scary concept for they who thought themselves to be the authority on what is legitimate text, writing, and literacy.

I wonder how much of this attitude I'm talking about pervades how much we as students participate or not--depending upon what paradigm we were raised in. I was raised revering printed text--books. Anything else was lesser somehow. It still strikes me as strange that I can go onto a blog written by professors for professors and comment on it. Who am I to make my voice heard in that forum? And yet, multimodality gives me a voice, and direct access to an author's ear, where before, I might merely have read their book and talked about it with my friends--there never would have been the equal interaction the multimodlity affords me.

That leads me back to my original point, but from a little different angle: call it chaos theory or rhetorical theory, people are interacting more around texts. Students can interact and even "argue" with their faculty (and authors of their textbooks), sometimes even via Facebook. That changes so many things. The paradigm seems to be shifting away from what things should be, to what they are; from authority to interaction. I see multimodal texts forcing those of the old paradigm of "words are a clear window we see thought through" to either close their eyes and become more irrelevant, or realize that rhetoric defines literacy too.

Literacy isn't above rhetorical theory, but subservient to it. Literacy is situated. It happens to be situated in the here and now, where nobody knows exactly what is going on. That chaos is cool. It gives "nobodies" a chance to talk to "somebodies", it makes "dead" texts that were stuck to one page now "alive" and interact-able-with. You know what I think? Is literacy at risk? Hell no! Literacy is more real and more accessible than ever before--but to see through that window, you have to be willing to shift your paradigm--perhaps into overdrive.

2 comments:

  1. Wow Angie! Your expose on these readings were quite thoughtful. I love living in an age where undermining the cultural authority of books is the norm. At least it is becoming the norm. It feels as if the pedestal of the author is pulled right from under his feet. The podium is now available to all, as you so astutely stated. I love being able to question a figure like Tom Woods, a historian with a unique perspective. His authority is challenged by my authority as his audience and possible contributor to his wealth as a customer. He owes me a certain respect that digitalization has made possible. Certainly i could have writen him a letter, but with busy lives, and being on the move responding to personal letters with all its intricacies of an address, an envelope, a stamp, and paper, it seems less feasible than responding to an email or comment on his website which may involve less steps in order to respond. The internet allows for an amalgamation of arts, sciences, music, philosophy, political science. One can be a connoisseur of them all, and be engaged in multiple conversations about them all simultaneously! Great post : )

    ReplyDelete
  2. Wow, I spelled Lanham's name wrong through the entire thing...an off week, sorry y'all.

    ReplyDelete