It's more than halfway through the semester and I finally think something is getting through my thick skull: the question is not What counts as writing? but What doesn't count as writing? Johnson-Eilola talks at length about Web Logs (blogs), and particularly on pages 216 and 217 about one called "Plastic", and as I was reading that section, I just got overwhelmed with the enormity of the different kinds of writing all going on all over this website, and how--as he says--none of it fits within the traditional rules of citation and authorship.
It seems like, when talking about writing or teaching writing, so many people focus most on issues of plagiarism, proper citation, and all that jazz. (Like the most important thing about writing is scaring people into being afraid to have any ideas based on other writers' ideas because that might be plagiarism...grrrrr--but I digress.) So, I'm wondering, if much of the writing going on in our world today doesn't even have the ability to fit into the very broad category of author and citation--if there are not even clear traditional roles in the field of writing (like editors and publishers), as we experience it today, how important are the ideas that are being harped upon that all have to do with those roles?
And yet I have to go back to what Johnson-Eilola says in the beginning, "exploring contradictions as necessary conditions of existence" (200). I can't say I grasp all of what he says throughout his article, so maybe he says this and I just can't grasp it yet, but I'm stuck on the question of how to make money as an author in a world where one doesn't just write old-fashioned, paper-and-bound books? I know he's talking about people being charged a lot of money to use tiny parts of texts, but we're talking about websites here--and I don't mean like Google. To bring it closer to home, I'm a blogger. I've written at least as much as a good-sized book in my posts. Do I make money off it? No. But without being a shameless advertisement whore, I don't know how (I can't bear the idea of whatever the Adsense Google app is that is supposed to earn me income off my blog--it just seems like so much salesmanship on writing that wasn't meant to be that; like putting coupons in a research book...). But Web Logs are such a media of the now--what I write wouldn't even go in a book--how do I further my writing career, not just my writing hobby? Looking forward to this conversation in class so I can understand more what J-E was talking about in terms of the money aspect of this.
Returning to my original question, What doesn't count as writing? I am toying with a kinda radical thought (to me): writing is every kind of human interaction we use, aside from face-to-face interaction. Ya think? And if that is true (I'm not sure that it is, but it's seeming plausible), then we don't use rhetoric in our writing at all: writing is rhetoric. If rhetoric is basic human interaction at its core (that is, we can't interact without using it), and writing is every kind of interaction we do other than in person, writing has to be rhetoric.
My head is spinning a little at those thoughts. I'd love to hear your thoughts for or against this craziness.
Great thoughts Angie, so great that you were boldly plagiarized, in order to prove a point. Or maybe to make a hasty web post--ha.
ReplyDeleteAt any rate, I didn't mind reading your thoughts twice, in your blog and Eli's.
And yeah, it does seem as though most things count as rhetoric.
I am overwhelmed by how writing is changing, and what it will mean in the future. Can we ride this wave of change and somehow use our passion for writing to "eat dinner?" I think so, but I have a lot to learn...
Thanks for the comment, Jenny. I got a good laugh out of Eli's post, actually. Like I commented to him, I didn't know my writing was worth citing. Or republishing. Or borrowing. Or whatever that was. As i also commented to him, I do wish he would've added some of his own thoughts to it, because I enjoy reading his blog and got jipped this time--I had to read my own twice and then comment on it!
ReplyDeleteThis brings up a point that has nothing to do with you or Eli personally--this just reminded me of something that bothers me. Just now I had to actually go look up "plagiarism" because even though I have some sense of it, I wasn't sure what it meant. Turns out nobody else is sure either. And yet don't we hear this issue harped upon as if it is the ultimate and unpardonable writing sin?
In lower level classes especially, I worry that writing instructors spend so much time instilling a fear of plagiarism that they will scare already-timid students away from the very process that grows ideas and builds knowledge. Don't we all get an idea from something we read or see, then build on it in our own directions? We cite, yes, but the lines are so blurry. Where does another's idea end and ours begin? It's not always so cut and dried.
At any rate, it seems to me that "plagiarism" refers more to a person using someone's work and pretending it's their own, without crediting the author. Eli didn't do that. And even if he had, it's no skin off my teeth, right?
This makes me wonder why the world is up in arms about this thing we can't even define. Jenny, maybe it has to do, like you commented on Eli's post, with when money comes into play? Or is it culture's obsession with "originality"? I don't know, but these are interesting thoughts y'all started.
Thanks for your comment--I agree, as long as we have a passion for writing, we'll find a way to eat dinner!
Another of the craziness that people bring into the teaching of writing I want to fight against is those who argue for the correct way to write (particularly language). Reading your rant on those concerned about plagerism, proper citation, etc., made me think about a recent professor I had (I'll leave it to the english majors to think whom) who always got on her students about proper grammar and proper language and docked major grade points for it, even if it was between two to four small mistakes per page. I think of this and think about the video about the man ( I cannot recall his name) who called those people "no more guardians of language than kennels are gaurdians of dogs." (love that quote). I'm fairly certain that I am making those same mistakes on this post, but who gives a damn now?
ReplyDeleteIf writing is everywhere, is it enough to just know how to write? What I mean is how do you gauge the value of a writer in terms of cash money money? I can type, cut/paste and stream ideas into media paste but there's no line outside of my door of perspective employers. Further, how much payment does the average text make? Not to sound like I feel I may be coming off as (dickish), but what if writing value is hidden in its context. I see, and have always seen writing as value added. Much like a computer, writing or more largely communicative skill, adds value to the exogenous variable - purpose.
ReplyDeletePerhaps when we find our purpose, the true value of communicative skill will be captured. Unless of course your purpose happens akin to the few who are purposed purely for writing, but how boring....
Interesting that after you say writing is everything but face-to-face interaction, we read the article about technology like Dragon, that can record what we are saying when we're in a face-to-face interaction. MAYBE EVERYTHING IS WRITING. (I hope so, that would make me feel much about my major in it).
ReplyDelete